Pay stub generators compared
EasyIncomeDocs vs. 123PayStubs
123PayStubs is a pay stub generator that also offers e-filing for a range of IRS forms. Here’s an honest look at how it compares to EasyIncomeDocs, so you can pick the service that actually fits what you need.
What 123PayStubs offers
123PayStubs currently advertises a free first pay stub, then $3.99 for each additional one, with several items priced as separate add-ons on top of that base price — including advanced federal & state withholding options, additional earnings/deductions, a deposit slip, and a time-off policy section, each billed individually per stub.* It also offers e-filing for forms like W-2 and 1099-NEC as a related service.
The difference
EasyIncomeDocs prices a pay stub at a single flat rate starting at $4.44 — additional earnings, deductions, and tax withholding detail are included, not billed as separate add-ons. You get a live preview that updates as you type, real federal and state tax withholding based on the IRS’s own published tables, and a no-login edit link after purchase if you need to make a correction.
Feature comparison
| Feature | EasyIncomeDocs | 123PayStubs |
|---|---|---|
| Pay stub generation | ||
| Online document creation | ||
| Real federal & state tax calculations | ||
| Live preview before you pay | Varies | |
| Flat, all-included pricing | ||
| Free edits/corrections after purchase | ||
| W-2 / 1099 e-filing | ||
| Other income documents (letters, invoices, etc.) | Limited | |
| Mobile app |
Feature availability and pricing can change and may depend on the current EasyIncomeDocs or 123PayStubs product offering. Check each provider's current product page before purchasing.
Choose EasyIncomeDocs if:
You want one flat price with earnings, deductions and tax detail already included, instead of tallying up separate add-on fees.
Choose 123PayStubs if:
You also need to e-file forms like W-2 or 1099-NEC directly with the IRS, or you want a mobile app for generating stubs on the go.
From $4.44
Create Your Pay StubSee how EasyIncomeDocs compares to other pay stub services:
*Pricing and features for 123PayStubs are based on publicly available information and can change at any time — check their site for current details. 123PayStubs is a trademark of its respective owner; this page is an independent comparison and isn’t affiliated with or endorsed by 123PayStubs.